Gift Ideas Under $25 - Reilly's Church Supply & Gift Boutique

0 Items - $0.00 My account / Register

Gift Ideas Under $25

Home / Gift Boutique / Christmas / Gift Ideas Under $25

Mud Pie Prayer Puzzle Stacker

Prayer Puzzle Stacker

Prayer Puzzle Stacker

$22.00

Mud Pie Petite Cross Necklace,

Petite Cross Necklace,

Petite Cross Necklace,

$24.99

Mud Pie Mug - Cardinal

$15.99

Harvest House First Light and Eventide: Daily Gratitude Journal

This easy-to-use journal encourages readers to bookend each day with short, personal reflections that bring insight and intentionality to their busy and unpredictable lives.

How can six simple questions help you better navigate life’s uncertainty?

First Light and Eventide: Daily Gratitude Journal

$22.99

Hirten Statue, Cold Cast Resin (4")

Cold Cast Resin Hand Painted Statue

Statue, Cold Cast Resin (4")

$18.75

Swanson Noah's Ark Peg/Jigsaw Puzzle

Ages 1+
Made of Smooth Wood
Measures 8.75″” x 8.75″” x .25
Vibrant Colors
Exciting and Inspiring Design

Teach your toddler and babies about the different animals and the story of Noah’s Ark in a colorful way that they will love! Inspire faith in Go

Noah's Ark Peg/Jigsaw Puzzle

$16.25

Swanson Tie - Circular Fish

100% Polyester
Hand Printed Design
Individually Polybagged with Hanger
Ready to Gift
Great for Father’s Day, Christmas, Birthday, and more

Looking for a stylish and trendy accessory to add to your wardrobe? Look no further than our handprinted men’

Tie - Circular Fish

$18.75

The Daily Grace Co. Mug - Adore

Adore Holiday mug features a maroon glazed finish and an embossed design that adds a beautiful texture.

Handcrafted with care, this 11 oz mug is perfect for your daily routine or as a special gift for a friend. Hand wash with soap for best results.

$22.00

Dayspring Devotional Journal - 100 Days of Faith Over Fear

Devotional Journal - 100 Days of Faith Over Fear

Devotional Journal - 100 Days of Faith Over Fear

$18.99

Dayspring Devotional Guide - Unfiltered: Living Raw, Real, & Redeemed by Jesus

We often think our lives should look a certain way to others, and we have the same idea about God. We try to bring only our best and hide the rest, a process that can lead to exhaustion, burnout, and disillusionment. But God hasn’t asked for our best; He’

Devotional Guide - Unfiltered: Living Raw, Real, & Redeemed by Jesus

$19.99

Dayspring Devotional Journal - Faith, Love, Forgiveness

Embark on a soul-nurturing journey crafted by licensed professional counselor, Susan Goss, who brings a unique blend of spiritual insight and therapeutic expertise to your fingertips. In this 10-week devotional journal, Susan integrates encouraging devoti

Devotional Journal - Faith, Love, Forgiveness

$17.99

Dayspring Perpetual Calendar - Peace

Embrace daily inspiration through this DayBrightener! This DayBrightener includes 366 hand-picked quotes, heartfelt truths, and hope-filled Scripture to remind and encourage you that peace is truly the gift that Jesus promised! This is an excellent gift f

Perpetual Calendar - Peace

$10.99

Dayspring Unrushed Living - Embracing Simplicity & Savoring Life's Moments

We’re moving faster and faster so that we’ll finally get there—wherever “there” is. But what if “there” was actually right here? Sopha Rush invites readers to examine why they’re in a hurry, burnt out, and under pressure to achieve or succeed. She offers

Unrushed Living - Embracing Simplicity & Savoring Life's Moments

$14.99

Christmas Journey Peace & Joy Linen Napkins (Set of 2)

Stay clean in style with the Peace & Joy Linen Napkins - Set of 2 from our Christmas Journey collection. A must-have kitchen accessory for everyday life or for all your festive parties!

Peace & Joy Linen Napkins (Set of 2)

$16.00

Christmas Journey Salt and Pepper Shakers - Nativity Lambs (Set of 2)

Season in style with the Nativity Lambs Salt and Pepper Shakers - Set of 2 from the Christmas Journey collection. Not only are these kitchen accessories functional, they're super cute too, making them a great decorative piece as well!

Salt and Pepper Shakers - Nativity Lambs (Set of 2)

$19.00

Bunnies by the Bay Wee Kiddo Lamb Plush

7 inches tall
Safe for all ages
Embroidered features
100% polyester
Surface wash/Spot clean

Wee Kiddo Lamb Plush

$22.50

Bunnies by the Bay Kiddo Lamb Silly Buddy Plush Pacifier Holder

Size: 10"
Safe for all ages
Embroidered Details
Lovey and Pacifier in one
Gentle rattle
100% polyester
Easy care; machine wash and dry low heat

Kiddo Lamb Silly Buddy Plush Pacifier Holder

$21.99

Roman Glass Block Message

4"H GLASS BLOCK MESSAGES 2/A
JESUS THE REASON/ KEEP CHRIST
Materials GLASS
Dimensions 4"H 4"W

Glass Block Message

$14.50

Roman Christmas Story Lapel Pin

2"H CHRISTMAS STORY PIN
BOXED
Materials 74%ZINC/10%PAINT/8%RHINESTONE/6%BRASS/4%
Dimensions 0.4"D 1.85"DIA

Christmas Story Lapel Pin

$24.99

Vermont Christmas Company Puzzle - Holy Manger (1000 Pieces)

1000 piece puzzle
26 5/8"x19 1/4" Completed
Fully interlocking and randomly shaped pieces
Produced on thick, premium quality puzzle board
Made with recycled materials
Quality craftsmanship

Puzzle - Holy Manger (1000 Pieces)

$22.50

Dayspring Prayers to Share: 100 Pass-Along Notes to Breathe & Release

Another addition to our top-selling series, designed to spread peace and reduce anxiety. Do you ever wish you could give someone the gift of a deep breath and a peaceful spirit? Prayers to Share: 100 Pass-Along Notes to Breathe & Release allows readers

Prayers to Share: 100 Pass-Along Notes to Breathe & Release

$11.99

Dayspring Refreshed: Meeting with Jesus, Becoming Love in Action - Devotional Guide

How would your life change if you woke up each morning with fresh hope and strength for the day?

What if the everyday tasks of life didn't weigh you down anymore, and you didn't have to run on autopilot or go through the motions just to "get through" e

Refreshed: Meeting with Jesus, Becoming Love in Action - Devotional Guide

$19.99

Dayspring Resting in Jesus: A 30 Day Walk with Mary & Martha

When our phones are pinging, children are crying, emails are pouring in, and the refrigerator is empty, finding time to rest in Jesus can seem like a near impossible task. If we aren’t being productive, we feel like missing out and falling behind. But Chr

Resting in Jesus: A 30 Day Walk with Mary & Martha

$19.99

Ignatius Press Restless Heart: The Confessions of Augustine DVD

A special 2-DVD collector's edition of the acclaimed epic film on St. Augustine of Hippo. Filmed in Europe, the first full-length feature movie on Augustine, it uses a historic backdrop to tell the true story of one of the Church's most beloved and well-k

Restless Heart: The Confessions of Augustine DVD

$16.95