Gift Ideas Under $25 - Reilly's Church Supply & Gift Boutique

0 Items - $0.00 My account / Register

Gift Ideas Under $25

Home / Gift Boutique / Christmas / Gift Ideas Under $25

Paraclete Press Share the Joy! A Christmas Lift-the-Flap Book

It's Christmas, and there is so much to be excited about! This lift-the-flap book helps kids explore and share all the fun, love, and true joy of this special time of year.

This first book from author, speaker, and mom Valerie Ellis celebrates all the

Share the Joy! A Christmas Lift-the-Flap Book

$14.99

Corda Corda Candle - Sweeter than Wine - Song of Songs

Our jar candle packaging now shares the story behind the inspiration!
Learn more here.

These amorous scents of cedar, pomegranate, and apple are inspired by the Song of Songs.

Nuanced with notes of clove, florals, balsam, patchouli, and musk.

B

Corda Candle - Sweeter than Wine - Song of Songs

$24.50

Roman Ornament - Glitter Cross

6.2"H GLITTER CROSS ORNAMENT
2A SILVER, GOLD AND PEARL
Materials PLASTIC
Dimensions 6.25"H

Ornament - Glitter Cross

$5.00

Hirten Rosary - April Birthstone, Crystal

One of our best sellers! Beautiful quality, affordable tin-cut aurora borealis birthstone rosaries. This shimmering tin-cut 6 mm Aurora Borealis 'April-Crystal' Birthstone Bead Rosary has a detailed silver oxidized 'Mary' center and stunning crucifix. Fin

Rosary - April Birthstone, Crystal

$18.75

Roman Footprints Standing Cross (4")

This standing cross makes a great gift for anyone needing a reminder of the reassuring love of God. 4" height. "When you saw only one set of Footprints it was then that I carried you."

Footprints Standing Cross (4")

$14.50

Corda Corda Candle - Marked by Love - St. Padre Pio

These fragrant scents of coffee and the odor of sanctity are inspired by St. Padre Pio.
Nuanced with notes of florals, vanilla, tobacco, wood, and musk.
Behind the Inspiration
This Capuchin friar was the first priest to bear the stigmata, which ga

Corda Candle - Marked by Love - St. Padre Pio

$24.50

Christian Art Gifts Colorful Stickers for Bible Journaling

Tap into your creative side with the Colorful Stickers for Bible Journaling.

These Colorful Bible Journaling Stickers include trendy and colorful stickers that have encouraging words of faith and lovely accents of nature. Add the stickers to your jou

Colorful Stickers for Bible Journaling

$5.00

Willow Tree Willow Tree Angel Stand

The Angel Stand is designed to elevate angels or figures in the Nativity collection. As enduring as the story it portrays, the Willow Tree Nativity is as loved today as when it was originally introduced in 2000. Its simplicity and form has made it a timel

Willow Tree Angel Stand

$21.00

Corda Corda Candle - Lauds - Morning Prayer

These invigorating scents of citrus, morning dew, and juniper berry are inspired by Lauds, the Morning Prayer of the Divine Office.

Behind the Inspiration

Morning Prayer, or Lauds, is the first office prayed after rising for the day. The fresh scen

Corda Candle - Lauds - Morning Prayer

$24.50

Mud Pie Cross & Handprint Kit,

Cross & Handprint Kit,

Cross & Handprint Kit,

$23.75

Kerusso Kidz Kids Shirt - Unicorn, Totally Unique

Unicorn™

Encourage your daughter to embrace her unique, God-given gifts and beautiful personality in this “Unicorn” Kerusso Kidz® Tee in Light Blue. She'll love the imaginative pastel design, and you'll love the sweet reminder that God has a plan for t

Kids Shirt - Unicorn, Totally Unique

$17.00

Roman Lighted Plaque, Sweet Dreams Collection

7.2"H LED SWEET DREAMS ACRYLIC TABLETOP PLAQUE
Materials ACRYLIC
Dimensions 7.25"H
Power Type 2 AA BATTERIES
Power Type Included N

Lighted Plaque, Sweet Dreams Collection

$23.25

Swanson Umbrella - Showers of Blessing

Our top selling Shower of Blessings Umbrella is a beautiful gift idea for women and girls. Shower of Blessings comes from the scripture Ezekiel 34:29 that says, “And I will make them and the places round about my hill a blessing; and I will cause the show

Umbrella - Showers of Blessing

$18.99

Swanson Socks - Heavens & Back

Unisex Socks
Fits Men’s Sizes 8-13
Fits Women’s Sizes 9 & Up
Cozy & Comfy
Stylish and Encouraging Design
Durable Cotton Blend

Introducing our fun and stylish unisex socks, perfect for anyone who wants to add some color and personality to their eve

Socks - Heavens & Back

$18.75

Swanson Tie - Green Cross

100% Polyester
Hand Printed Design
Individually Polybagged with Hanger
Ready to Gift
Great for Father’s Day, Christmas, Birthday, and more

Looking for a stylish and trendy accessory to add to your wardrobe? Look no further than our handprinted men’

Tie - Green Cross

$18.75

Christian Art Gifts 2025 Wall Calendar - The Lord Will Guide You Always

Remember that God carefully plans each day of your life when you use The LORD Will Guide You Always 2025 Large Wall Calendar.

This large calendar's olive green front cover introduces its floral theme with white and pale pink flowers. The sentiment is p

2025 Wall Calendar - The Lord Will Guide You Always

$7.99

$4.79

The Daily Grace Co. Isaiah 40:31 Accessory Pouch - Natural

Isaiah 40:31 Accessory Pouch - Natural has arrived! This accessory pouch is a great way to keep a few of your favorite resources all together. Use it as…

A central storage spot for your verse cards, highlighters, prayer request lists, notepads, and mor

Isaiah 40:31 Accessory Pouch - Natural

$23.00

Tan Books (St. Benedict Press) Mother to Mother

The unique ability of women to be mothers is a most precious gift. Whether a woman’s vocation is to be a mother in the context of married life or the spiritual motherhood of religious life, both vocations have Our Lady as their source and inspiration. Thi

Mother to Mother

$24.95

Dayspring Country Faith: 70 Inspired Stories from Leading Country Music Stars

With personal stories from Carrie Underwood, Alan Jackson, Trisha Yearwood, Steven Curtis Chapman, and dozens of other top and rising country music stars, Country Faith: 70 Inspired Stories from Leading Country Music Stars is a perfect gift for music love

Country Faith: 70 Inspired Stories from Leading Country Music Stars

$18.99

Roman Christmas Cross Tree Lapel Pin

2.5"H XMAS CROSS TREE PIN
CARDED
Materials ZINC
Dimensions 2.5"H

Christmas Cross Tree Lapel Pin

$19.99

Paraclete Press My Tender Heart Devotions

My Tender Heart Devotions introduces little ones to weekly reflections with 52 Bible-based readings and rhymes. Encourage young readers to learn and grow in their relationship with God through this uplifting and interactive book of devotions!

My Tender

My Tender Heart Devotions

$15.99

Vermont Christmas Company Puzzle - The Greatest Story (550 Pieces)

550 piece puzzle
24"x18" Completed
Fully interlocking and randomly shaped pieces
Produced on thick, premium quality puzzle board
Made with recycled materials
Quality craftsmanship

Puzzle - The Greatest Story (550 Pieces)

$20.00

Thomas Nelson Jesus Today

Do you need hope for your discouragement and healing for your hurts? Written from Jesus' perspective Jesus Today ® assures you that He is in control, that He is good, and that a glorious future awaits all who trust in Him. Jesus Today, is the follow-up to

$16.99

The Daily Grace Co. The Gospel of Mark Bible Study - Follow Me

Follow Me | A Study on the Gospel of Mark | 6 Week Study

Have you ever wrestled with doubt or struggled with faith?

Follow Me is an in depth study on the gospel of Mark. The gospel of Mark is an invitation to follow Jesus. It invites us to step forw

The Gospel of Mark Bible Study - Follow Me

$20.00